Why I’d pick a Steam Machine over a PS5

By Gaming On Steam ·

This is my Steam Machine review after months of living with one. There is no getting around the price: a PS5 is $650 in this comparison, and the cheapest Steam Machine is $1,049 on Valve’s US store. I checked that Machine figure today; the official UK starting price is £879. Hardware prices can change, so it is worth confirming before you buy. This Steam Machine vs PS5 comparison is about what you actually get over the years you own the box, not just the price on the sticker. I still think it is the better living-room buy if your Steam library is already huge and you want a box that does more than play the games Sony has approved.

It is a real PC, not just a console

A PS5 does what Sony lets it do. The Steam Machine runs SteamOS, and with one button press you are in a full Linux desktop: a web browser, a file manager, and the apps you actually want to install. Netflix in a browser on the TV is easy. That is a small example, but it is the point. This is a PC that happens to sit under the television.

That also opens the door to other stores. Using a free tool, I added the Epic Games Store, GOG and Ubisoft Connect right into gaming mode, so those libraries play on the same box. You can set up emulators for older systems, as long as you are playing games you own. On the PC versions of games, you get mods. Valve also made the SSD and the RAM accessible and upgradeable, which is not something you get on a sealed console.

One Steam library across every Steam device

If you already have a Steam Deck, a Steam Frame or a gaming PC, the Steam Machine just slots in. It is the same account and the same games. Steam Cloud saves, on supported titles, mean you can start something on the TV and pick it up on the Deck in bed. Steam Families lets you share that library with up to five other people in your household. On PlayStation, you are buying into a separate ecosystem that only works on PlayStation. I looked at how these devices fit together in an earlier Steam Deck, Steam Machine and Steam Frame piece; this is the part of that lineup that still matters most to me in the living room.

Online play does not need a subscription

To play most games online on a PS5, you need PlayStation Plus. The cheapest tier, Essential, is $79.99 a year, or $10.99 a month if you pay monthly. Those are the official US rates I checked; free-to-play games are the exception. On the Steam Machine, there is no subscription for online multiplayer. You buy the game and you play it online.

The bit that surprised me is the long-term maths. Five years of PS Plus Essential at that yearly price comes to about $400, which is almost exactly the gap between a $650 PS5 and the $1,049 base Steam Machine. You can argue about how many years you will keep the box, but that is a real cost sitting next to the sticker prices.

Games get cheaper on Steam

Steam sales are a big part of this. The winter sale starts on 17 December and runs into January, and there are seasonal sales and publisher deals all year. Because it is a PC, you can also buy from other PC stores and still play on the same machine. Steam’s refund policy helps as well: if something is not for you, you can ask for a refund within two weeks, as long as you have played it for less than two hours. Over a few years, the money you save on games can make a real dent in that higher upfront price.

You already own the games, and they run well

This is the big one for me. If you have been on Steam for years, you might have hundreds of games already. On a PS5, you would be starting again. On the Steam Machine, that library is ready on day one. Thanks to Proton, a huge number of Windows games just work, and in my testing they run well. I have already written up five games that surprised me on Steam Machine, and the same picture holds here.

Dune: Awakening ran at full 4K on the high preset at 50 to 60 frames a second. Cyberpunk 2077 got 60-plus at 1440p on high. Silent Hill: Townfall hit 4K at 60 with FSR on Ultra Performance. Star Wars Galactic Racer held a solid 60 at 1440p, and Onimusha ran at 60 on ultra at 1080p; on a 4K TV at 1440p it still looked excellent. I think the take that performance is roughly in PS5 territory is fair. The difference is that you are playing games you have already paid for, at settings you choose, with the option to tweak things like upscaling and frame rate caps yourself. For me, that is huge. If you want to squeeze a bit more out of the picture, I also put together 10 Steam Machine tips for performance and picture.

Steam Machine review: who it is for, and who should get a PS5

It is not the right pick for everyone. The upfront price is higher, and the base $1,049 model does not come with a controller; Valve’s US store lists the 512 GB Machine with a controller at $1,128. A PS5 Pro is more powerful, with a stronger GPU and Sony’s own AI upscaling. Some games with anti-cheat still do not work on SteamOS right now, including Fortnite, Valorant, Call of Duty and Battlefield 6. PlayStation exclusives come to PC late, if at all, and GTA 6 launches on consoles first on 19 November. Valve is also still working through its reservation queue, so buying one is not always as simple as clicking a button today.

If you mostly play Sony exclusives or those big competitive shooters, a PS5 still makes a lot of sense. But if your Steam library is already huge and you want a box that does more than one thing, I really think the Steam Machine is the better buy.

More videos

View channel →